Back

Reviews Antica Trattoria La Toppa

9/10

Excellent

based on 178 reviews
Only customers who have dined at the restaurant after making a reservation on TheFork can leave a review.
  1. Antonia H.
    Antonia H.
    • 5 reviews
    9/10

    Tutto exquisito!

  2. Andrea M.
    Andrea M.
    • one review
    10/10

    Excellent food and excellent host. We had tagliatelle with duck ragù and they were exquisite!

  3. Kasia F.
    Kasia F.
    • one review
    10/10

    Exquisit in all aspects. One of my best dinners ever. And absolutely fabulous service and very welcoming owners.

  4. David B.
    David B.
    • one review
    8/10

    Great small historic restaurant set in a medical walked town. Attentive service, good food and wine. In the summer the tables are all along the street.

  5. Leonardo F.
    Leonardo F.
    • 6 reviews
    10/10

    Best restaurant I’ve been to when I search for an authentic Tuscan cuisine. Might be a bit pricy compared your other trattorias but here you get the real vibe of the region! I highly recommend going with your friends and family to share this exasperating experience! 10/10 food, service, location !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  6. Maura H.
    Maura H.
    • one review
    10/10

    We have been visiting this restaurant for the past 26 years anytime we’ve been in Tuscany and the standard is as good today as it was on our first visit - absolutely fantastic

  7. Oksana S.
    Oksana S.
    • one review
    8/10

    REally overrated and oriented to tourist. Most expensive mel with smallest portions in whole trip.

  8. Neeta B.
    Neeta B.
    • one review
    10/10

    Excellent food and extremely good service a great family run restaurant

  9. Christine Vagstad J.
    Christine Vagstad J.
    • one review
    9.5/10

    Deliciously food and great atmosphere!!

  10. Helge Knut H.
    Helge Knut H.
    • one review
    9/10

    Excellent food with wonderful italian family Service. We will definately come back!

  11. Chloe B.
    Chloe B.
    • one review
    10/10

    Delicious authentic food served by charming people!

  12. Michael J.
    Michael J.
    • one review
    10/10

    Great place great owners great food

  13. Jenny G.
    Jenny G.
    • 5 reviews
    8/10

    cosy restaurant and good food. Worth the visit.

  14. Josh P.
    Josh P.
    • 5 reviews
    10/10

    Lovely outdoor setting, delicious food and engaging staff. Couldn't fault it.

  15. Marlies V.
    Marlies V.
    • 4 reviews
    10/10

    Very friendly staff and great typical Italian food!

  16. Isabel W.
    Isabel W.
    • one review
    10/10

    Perfect Restaurant! We book a table for tomorrow too

  17. Betsy B.
    Betsy B.
    • 2 reviews
    10/10

    We had dinner on our last evening in this lovely restaurant in this beautiful medieval town. It was a stunning evening and a capstone to our first visit to Tuscany. Thank you to our hosts !

  18. Shane T.
    Shane T.
    • 2 reviews
    9/10

    Service & food in this hidden village gem was excellent!

  19. Maurizio V.
    Maurizio V.
    • 2 reviews
    7/10

    Da non perdere le pappardelle.

  20. Istvan  U.
    Istvan U.
    • 3 reviews
    3/10

    We visited on a Saturday night, the restaurant had no music or ambiance. When we sat down the waiter gave us a weird look because we didn't take any wine. We were both full of cold so the last thing I wanted was to drink. We only had a main course and a pasta. It was ok, overpriced and average at best. After our food I asked for the bill, then the owner sat down to our table. First he had a go with my wife, why she is on her phone instead of eating more food?!! We already asked for the bill !! After he said we didn't eat enough, finally he started to write up our bill, by sitting at our table asking what we had???! Strange they don't write down! It took about 5 min as he went through the whole menu asking what we didn't have, making a point we didn't eat enough. Finally he finished the bill, I gave him my credit card which he refused to take saying we didn't spend enough money to pay with card?? Eventually he took our card and we could pay our bill. He did change us 2 euros twice for bread which we didn't have also 10 percent service charge. He didn't thank at all when we payed. Over all very bad experience the place isn't genuine and really badly run. After we left we had a little walk around the town and we were realising how busy it was everywhere else it all made sense! I wouldn't recommend to go there!

  21. Christian B.
    Christian B.
    • 6 reviews
    2.5/10

    Low quality food, no atmosphere...and a criminal owner (the old one) who really pushs you to pay cash and becomes angry when you pay per card. Maybe I tell the gardia financa... You better book something else!

  22. - -.
    - -.
    • one review
    10/10

    Good food, very nice owners

  23. - -.
    - -.
    • one review
    10/10

    As folks who only speak a little Italian well, we appreciated the service and that they let me botch their language as I tried to speak in Italian :) The view and food were AMAZING!

  24. Nathan M.
    Nathan M.
    • 8 reviews
    10/10

    Amazing pasta, really enjoyed Beef Stew.

  25. Renaud M.
    Renaud M.
    • 58 reviews
    8/10

    La toppa is a famous old cosy restaurant of San Donato in Poggio located in a very beautiful old street. the owner is very friendly and makes effort to make you feel good. the quality of the food is very good and the price are ok.

  26. Erica B.
    Erica B.
    • 5 reviews
    5/10

    This restaurant serves delicious pasta and reasonable mains and deserts but we left feeling that we had been ripped off. We made the mistake of ordering the waiter's recommendations without seeing a menu. We should have asked to see one. The bill, for this type of restaurant, was significantly larger than we expected. It included a service charge of 18 euro - 2 euro per person for our group of eight plus baby. Yes, they even charged service for the baby, despite the fact that the parents and baby left after the pasta course as the baby wouldn't settle. We were also charged 30 euro for 3 side dishes - a very ordinary salad, a plate of white beans and a plate of the spinach. Sides at a similar (very good) family restaurant a couple of days earlier were 4 euro per plate.