Captain Stirling Hotel

Ian S.

April 30, 2023 • 32 reviews

10/10

We had the fish and chips the serve was huge batter was very nice we also shared a steak sandwich once again very nice chips were hot and the house slaw was one of the best staff very nice and welcoming would recommend to everyone

Captain Stirling Hotel (Owner)

Thank you so much for your review Ian - we hope to see you back at Cap S soon!

Raymond S.

March 31, 2023 • 13 reviews

7.5/10

Nice and quiet Friday night. Food came out relatively quickly. I enjoyed the steak sandwich and wife had the fish and chips (grilled) with kale salad.

Carol B.

March 17, 2023 • 3 reviews

9/10

Used the Fork app and had a $50 discount due to accumulated yums! Was told there would be a half hour wait due to a big seniors group ordering before us but it didn’t take that long. We had a margarita pizza and the porterhouse steak with chips and slaw, I opted for no sauce. Portions were generous and food was excellent. Next time we will grab a table away from the lily pond as once the food came out the bugs were swarming. Ambience was lovely although a tad noisy due to the Stirling Hwy, but we will return!

Karen K.

February 27, 2023 • 228 reviews

6/10

Very limited vegetarian menu. Yes I know it’s a pub but dinner options other than a sandwich or a margarita pizza would be appreciated

Esther C.

January 19, 2023 • 48 reviews

5.5/10

Nuggets and arancini were over cooked and nicer if fried to a golden brown rather than dark nearly burnt. Calamari and chips was served without salad and sauce as pictured in the menu making it a too dry meal. Asked for bbq sauce and was served tomato sauce. Ordered beer and was not served beer. Chocolate cake was like a mud cake. Takeaway was late and no paper bag only trash bags. Good service from person who took order and disappointing service from kitchen and subsequent team member.

Melanie M.

January 10, 2023 • 3 reviews

9/10

Great staff and service: Downside for ordering through the menu ap is some items list as unavailable but they are available when you ask at the bar and items ordered through the ap run out so staff have to come and ask you to change your order. Only complaint is we ordered the lobster special which was listed as grilled lobster with chips and salad. It is in fact 1/2 a lobster which I think should be specified and the lobster had already been removed from the shell turn out back in so was quite dry when reheated and served. Staff are amazing, I booked through the ap at 10am but they didn’t receive the booking until 45 min before we arrived and they still accommodated us and were super friendly and efficient.

Captain Stirling Hotel (Owner)

Hi Melanie, Thanks for the review. It was an absolute pleasure hosting you and your guests. We look forward to welcoming you back soon. Warmest Regards, The Captain Stirling Hotel

Esther C.

January 9, 2023 • 48 reviews

8/10

Lobster was a pleasant surprise, tender and warm covered by flavoursome herb and garlic butter and served with generous portion of chips and salad. All other meals were served with generous portion of chips. Good selection of alcoholic and nonalcoholic drinks.

Captain Stirling Hotel (Owner)

Hi Esther, Thanks for the review. We look forward to welcoming you back soon. Warmest Regards, The Captain Stirling Hotel

Linda M.

November 27, 2022 • 39 reviews

10/10

Always a great place

Captain Stirling Hotel (Owner)

Thank you for your review! It is always a pleasure welcoming people into our pub and we hope we can welcome you again soon! -The Captain Stirling Hotel

Raymond S.

November 26, 2022 • 13 reviews

8.5/10

Lovely meal. Staff are super friendly. Delicious food.

Captain Stirling Hotel (Owner)

Thank you for your review! We appreciate your feedback, and hope we can welcome you in again soon! -The Captain Stirling Hotel

Mark J.

August 17, 2022 • 29 reviews

3.5/10

Do not go here if hoping to redeem your yum points on any specials - THEY WILL NOT USE THEM FOR SPECIALS also the menu prices have not been ‘updated’ and meals have supposedly increased in price but you will not find this out until you pay

Jeanne O.

August 13, 2022 • 21 reviews

8/10

We had the lamb shank, scotch fillet and salmon. Lamb Shank was on the smaller side but delicious. Love the sauce. On menu it states red wine jus but tasted like bovril/marmite. Scotch Fillet was also good but per our previous dining experience, the sauces still need improving. Son had the garlic sauce and it was watery but he said it tasted good. The Kitchen should attempt to get the sauces right and everything would be perfect. Salmon had the slightly crispy (could be more crisp) skin with a very generous serve of salad. I am nearly always dismayed by the small serving of sides with the main but not here. The serving staff were all a delight too.

Captain Stirling Hotel (Owner)

Good morning Jeanne! Thank you for taking the time to give us your feedback, we are always looking for ways to improve our service. Hope to see you again soon!

Jeanne O.

June 4, 2022 • 21 reviews

9/10

Very pleasant and friendly server. The Tomahawk special was really good value and cooked medium rare as requested. However, pepper sauce didn't taste peppery at all and could be much thicker too. Like the addition of the onion rings and corn on top of the salad & chips.

Captain Stirling Hotel (Owner)

Thanks Jeanne!

Patricia O.

May 8, 2022 • 2 reviews

8/10

We loved the restaurant, lots of character being Mothers Day the staff treated us really special and enjoyed the lovely gift of macaroons waiting at our table. I ordered the salt n pepper squid a bit disappointed as a bit of salad or garnish would of been nice and if the squid was not the rings you get in the fish n chip shop but my mother enjoyed her meal. Would go back as my mum loved it.

Captain Stirling Hotel (Owner)

Hello there, Thank you for taking the time to provide us some feedback, we really appreciate hearing from you and are pleased you felt special for mothers day and enjoyed your visit. We have passed on the information about the squid and garnish to our chef for you.

Craig S.

April 7, 2022 • 30 reviews

6/10

The menu has been changed significantly not offering salad with anything even when asked to substitute it from a slaw. Very little to choose from. The staff were great I feel it was the menu that let them down today

Captain Stirling Hotel (Owner)

Hi Craig We do apologise if you current visit was not up to standard, we do have our new winter menu coming out soon and hope you do return. We value our customers feedback and have passed this onto the chef as well. We are pleased though you enjoyed the service at this time.

Anne G.

March 29, 2022 • 43 reviews

8/10

Good value meals. If you are looking for a good pub meal I would definitely recommend Captain Stirling Hotel. The staff & the service was very good.

Captain Stirling Hotel (Owner)

That's amazing to hear Anne, we are delighted you enjoyed your visit to the captain stirling and look forward to seeing you again really soon

Gerard C.

March 12, 2022 • 49 reviews

8/10

Nice local nosherie - relaxed vibe with feeling of space and relaxed outside seating options - standard pub fare but tasty dishes - decent set of taps

See photo

Captain Stirling Hotel (Owner)

Hi there Gerard, We do appreciate you giving feedback, and we are pleased you enjoyed your visit and the meals you received. Looking forward to seeing you all again soon

Terri D.

March 6, 2022 • 1 review

9.5/10

All 12 of us enjoyed our meals. Very generous serves and the staff were lovely. Nothing was too hard for them when we made requests. Special shout out to Kate for looking after us with a smile thank you!

Captain Stirling Hotel (Owner)

Hi Terri What a lovely review! thank you for the kind words, as always we value feedback so we can improve any way we can. See you all again soon

Denise M.

March 1, 2022 • 40 reviews

6/10

Ribs were a bit tough

Captain Stirling Hotel (Owner)

Hi Denise, We do apologise you didnt enjoy the ribs this visit, if you would like to call the venue we would love to discuss this more with you. We appreciate the feedback

Chris D.

January 22, 2022 • 13 reviews

8/10

Typical pub grub that makes for a pleasant evening out at our local.

Captain Stirling Hotel (Owner)

Hi Chris, Lovely to hear from you, we are pleased you enjoyed your visit and the meals and service we provide. See you again soon

David Oh

December 31, 2021 • 14 reviews

7/10

Waiter really need to be taught not to be rude. He will collect your plates away without asking if you have finished eating and totally no manners when talking to you.

Captain Stirling Hotel (Owner)

Hi David Thank you for taking the time to provide a review. We value the feedback and are always looking for ways to improve. We apologise that unfortunately on this occasion we seem to have fallen short. We will speak with the staff involved and this will be dealt with accordingly. If you feel we can improve in any other way please don't hesitate to contact us via phone or email and we will make it a priority to get back to you.