Back

Reviews - Osteria Pagliazza

8.6/10

Fabulous

based on 565 reviews
Only customers who have dined at the restaurant after making a reservation on TheFork can leave a review.
  1. Rodrigo M.
    Rodrigo M.
    • 15 reviews
    8/10

    Every dish is very expensive and not really worth it's price. A water costs 7 euros.

  2. Francesco M.
    Francesco M.
    • 8 reviews
    10/10

    Ottimo

  3. Gabriele B.
    Gabriele B.
    • 25 reviews
    10/10

    ottimo

  4. Jonas E.
    Jonas E.
    • 8 reviews
    10/10

    Very good food and a comprehensive wine list. The price matches the quality of the kitchen. Beautiful outside terrace in a quiet courtyard.

  5. Karina R.
    Karina R.
    • 18 reviews
    9/10

    We loved the atmosphere and the team has been extremely pleasant, helpful and prepared. Our expectations were higher on the menu but overall good feedback on the dishes we tasted. As a starter they “offered us” an amouse bouche from the chef. When we asked for the bill we realized that they had charged it per person.

  6. Antonio G.
    Antonio G.
    • 26 reviews
    10/10

    Top in tutto

  7. Lars D.
    Lars D.
    • 2 reviews
    8.5/10

    Very good food, but expensive drinks. 20Eur for an Aperol Spritz or 6 Eur for an espresso is way too much for Florence.

  8. Oscar V.
    Oscar V.
    • 15 reviews
    10/10

    Good place to share with couple. Nice service and. Good food

  9. Andrea o.
    Andrea o.
    • 11 reviews
    9/10

    Osteria... di lusso

  10. Peter W.
    Peter W.
    • 70 reviews
    9.5/10

    Pleasant, quiet bistro of the Hotel Brunelleschi. We had wonderful sea scallops, perfectly cooked, seasoned with saffron on a bed of leeks, followed by cacio e pepe spaghetti and shrimps. A nice bottle of white Lugana from I Frati, all very reasonably priced, thanks to the generous Fork discount.

  11. George B.
    George B.
    • 2 reviews
    10/10

    A quiet enjoyable meal with my wife in a romantic restaurant. The food was beautifully prepared and the service was excellent.

  12. Ekaterina R.
    Ekaterina R.
    • 3 reviews
    9/10

    Wonderful atmosphere in the heart of Florence

  13. David J.
    David J.
    • 3 reviews
    8.5/10

    Very nice cuisine.

  14. Ami N.
    Ami N.
    • 5 reviews
    9/10

    Great service. Portions small but delicious!!!

  15. Kate b.
    Kate b.
    • one review
    10/10

    A lovely meal and overall enjoyable experience. Very attentive staff-would highly recommend

  16. William C.
    William C.
    • 6 reviews
    10/10

    Absolutely stunning. Staff are very attentive and very friendly with wine recommendations and suggestions. Only our second review on here, even though we have made several bookings but, this deserves an award. FANTASTIC

  17. Mario Alexis P.
    Mario Alexis P.
    • 21 reviews
    10/10

    Outside of the desert, the food was incredibly fresh, refined and terrific. Service was 1st class!! Compliments to the chef and the staff!

  18. Eleonora w.
    Eleonora w.
    • 2 reviews
    10/10

    Restaurant in the center inside a small alley, happened to see the discount, Indoor and outdoor are very good very quiet place and few people past, the waiter recommended pumpkin sauce beef is very good, because the replacement part of the menu what i want to eat, I ll taste the next time.

  19. - -.
    - -.
    • 2 reviews
    8/10

    Delicious food, cosy atmosphere, overlooking the small Piazza.

  20. Marie G.
    Marie G.
    • 4 reviews
    10/10

    Amazing food! Amazing staff! We had a really great time!

  21. Vittoria M.
    Vittoria M.
    • 4 reviews
    10/10

    Love this restaurant! I'll come back early!

  22. Cristiane G.
    Cristiane G.
    • one review
    6/10

    Nice looking place but the service was a little slow, even tho he was great. I expected more from my food. I had the shrimp linguini and it was just ok.

  23. Tim M.
    Tim M.
    • 7 reviews
    9.5/10

    Very nice restaurant with good food. Even better with the 50% off from thefork!

    Osteria Pagliazza

    Dear Guest, Thank you so much for sharing your experience at our Osteria della Pagliazza with us. All information and details that you have given are precious to us. We are extremely honored to hear that you have enjoyed our restaurant and that you appreciated our Menu. Thank you very much as well for your kind words : our daily important effort is directed to make unforgettable your experience in Florence. Thank you for taking time to review our property . We truly trust in welcome you again at Osteria della Pagliazza. We invite you to visit our Facebook page or the Magazine on our website to be kept up to date on our latest news. Kindest regards, Carla Balli Guest relation

  24. Salvatore Z.
    Salvatore Z.
    • 19 reviews
    10/10

    Excellent food, great atmosphere, in the heart of Florence. The maitre prepared a wonderful crepes live cooking in front of us. To be back here for sure.

    Osteria Pagliazza

    Dear Guest, We want to thank you for sharing your experience at our Osteria Pagliazza in Florence. All information and details that you have given are absolutely precious to us, and will permit us to improve our service. We are happy to understand that you completely enjoy the dinner at our Osteria della Pagliazza and we thank you for the beautiful words: our daily commitment is to making an unforgettable experience for our guests, and your feeling is for us the bigger prize. Thanks for your words about our food and service: these are shared with our Chef and Maitre. We would be delighted to welcome you back to Osteria La Pagliazza and we would like to invite you to visit our Facebook page or the Magazine on our website to be kept up to date on the latest news. With my warmest regards Carla Balli Guest Relation

  25. Sukru A.
    Sukru A.
    • 21 reviews
    9.5/10

    Excellent price quality in a good atmosphere.

  26. Emanuele p.
    Emanuele p.
    • 26 reviews
    7/10

    Nice hotel restaurant, good food's quality but not so much choice

  27. - -.
    - -.
    • one review
    4.5/10

    The menu was disappointing.They advertise themselves as a Vegan reastaurant but we had to ask for menu and it did not really exist. Perculiar not to have starters. The setting was horriible. Just eating in the bar basically. Would not recommend it at all

    Osteria Pagliazza

    Dear Guest, We thank you very much for your kind comment and for sharing your experience with The Fork community: this affords us to improve our daily commitment to reach Guest expectations. We feel astonished for the evidence of our failure; provoking bad feeling is absolutely not usual to us, but only comfortable and pleasant memories to bring home, as the majority of our Guests testify with their reviews. We deeply regret that the Vegan choices proposed on our Menu did not meet your expectations. Our Restaurant Menu include the most traditional Tuscan dishes, revised by our Chef , some of the Slow Food specialties, Flambè dishes, as well as some Vegan options. All our dishes are listed on the Menu. We cannot change what happened nor the experience you had , but we hope they could accept our Apologies and you could consider to give us a second chance to make your Dinner unforgettable, We remain at your complete disposal, with my warmest regards Fabiola Menchetti Hotel Manager

  28. Sean M.
    Sean M.
    • 7 reviews
    10/10

    A lovely rtestaurant in a quiet area not very far from the Duomo. Service was first class (thank you Beata), food well presented and very well cooked. We took one the Tuscan menus at 44 Euro per person which included a bottle of wine and a glass of Prosecco. Excellent value. Our only complaint .......... there was too much food and it was too nice to leave any!

  29. Gaëtan N.
    Gaëtan N.
    • 3 reviews
    10/10

    Great food and excellent service