Only with offersNearby
Register my restaurant
Help

The 5 Best Italian Restaurants in Sheffield

7 restaurants
Why you received these results
Italian - Vito's Italian Restaurant, Sheffield
Top Rated

Pizzeria

Vito's Italian Restaurant

284 South Road, S6 3TE, Sheffield

9.7 / 10
134 reviews

Average price £40

Dessert of Tiramisu was the best ever! Hope to return Soon

    Rigatoni pasta cooked al dente, coated in a rich tomato sauce with herbs and vegetable chunks, garnished with fresh basil.

    Italian

    Tradita Pasta Bar And Tapas

    227 Abbeydale Road, S7 1FJ, Sheffield

    9.3 / 10
    6 reviews

    Average price £20

    30% off food

    Excellent food with a very reasonably priced bottle of wine

      Italian - The Admiral Rodney, Sheffield

      Pizzeria

      The Admiral Rodney

      592 Loxley Road, S6 6RU, Sheffield

      9.8 / 10
      21 reviews

      Average price £25

      Great family meal on a Saturday night

      • 12:00
      • 12:15
      • 12:30
      • 12:45
      • 13:00
      Italian - The Mossbrook, Sheffield

      Pizzeria

      The Mossbrook

      Sheffield Road, S21 4FP, Sheffield

      8.7 / 10
      31 reviews

      Average price £30

      Service great . Nice surroundings. Will go back

      • 12:00
      • 12:15
      • 12:30
      • 12:45
      • 13:00
      Italian - The Prince of Wales - Sheffield, Sheffield

      Pizzeria

      The Prince of Wales - Sheffield

      95 Ecclesall Road South, S11 9PH, Sheffield

      8.7 / 10
      49 reviews

      Average price £30

      Great food and service definitely worth a visit...

      • 12:00
      • 12:15
      • 12:30
      • 12:45
      • 13:00
      The Golden Ball, Rotherham

      Pizzeria

      The Golden Ball

      Turner Lane, S60 4HY, Rotherham

      9.8 / 10
      20 reviews

      Average price £27

      We had a great night, food was good Service was first rate

      • 12:00
      • 12:15
      • 12:30
      • 12:45
      • 13:00
      Pizza topped with tender beef, thinly sliced red onions, melted golden cheese, and slivers of almonds on a golden brown crust.

      Pizzeria

      The Fox House

      Hathersage Rd Longshaw, S11 7TY, Longshaw, Sheffield

      6.6 / 10
      38 reviews

      Average price £27

      Great fish and chips washed down with a lovely beer

      • 12:00
      • 12:15
      • 12:30
      • 12:45
      • 13:00
      Discover our suggestions
      We have a large variety of restaurants that might interest you based on your search

      Best rated restaurants in Sheffield

      Fresh salad with grilled chicken, diced mango, red onion, and sesame seeds, drizzled with creamy dressing, accompanied by crispy croquettes with a soft filling.

      Spanish Wine bar

      Styr Bistro

      Score:9.9

      S7 2QF Sheffield

      £20 average price

      Persian With friends

      Abadan Persian Restaurant

      Score:9.5

      S7 1FS Sheffield

      £26 average price

      Indian With friends

      Delhi In Minutes

      Score:9.4

      S17 3GU Sheffield

      £27 average price

      Best deals in Sheffield

      British Salida en grupos

      Signature Grillhouse

      S35 3UH Sheffield

      £30 average price

      Up to -50%

      Modern restaurant interior with a tufted brown leather banquette, warm wooden tables, and charming floral arrangements, creating a cozy and sophisticated atmosphere.

      Greek Lunch

      The Greek grill house

      Score:9.1

      S10 1ED Sheffield

      £23 average price

      Up to -30%

      The restaurant interior boasts a modern design with plush teal seating, wooden accents, and vertical wooden paneling, creating a warm atmosphere enhanced by soft ambient lighting from decorative pendant lights.

      Indian With friends

      Raazi

      Score:7.3

      S8 0ZT Sheffield

      £20 average price

      Up to -20%

      You may also like in Sheffield

      Fresh salad with grilled chicken, diced mango, red onion, and sesame seeds, drizzled with creamy dressing, accompanied by crispy croquettes with a soft filling.

      Spanish Wine bar

      Styr Bistro

      Score:9.9

      S7 2QF Sheffield

      £20 average price

      Persian With friends

      Abadan Persian Restaurant

      Score:9.5

      S7 1FS Sheffield

      £26 average price

      Indian With friends

      Delhi In Minutes

      Score:9.4

      S17 3GU Sheffield

      £27 average price

      Italian near Sheffield

      • Italian Stockport 45.7 km
      • Italian Leeds 47.0 km

      More food types in Sheffield

      • Burger
      • European
      • Vegan dishes
      • Indian
      • Vegetarian dishes
      Handmade pasta, stone-oven pizza, gooey steaming risotto, and mouth-watering tiramisu; Italian cooking comes straight from the heart and hearth. From Naples, Venice, or Florence, treat yourself to a delicious meal from our selection of the best Italian restaurants.

      Download our App

      • Download from the App Store
      • Get it on Google Play
      • About
      • Loyalty program
      • Contact
      • Terms of Use
      • Are you a restaurant?
      • Privacy and Cookies Statement
      • Frequently asked questions
      • We are hiring
      • MICHELIN Guide Partnership
      • Restaurant near me

      © 2025 La FourchetteSAS - All rights reserved

      Promotional offers are subject to conditions displayed on the restaurant’s page. Offers on alcoholic beverages are strictly reserved for adults. Alcohol abuse is dangerous for your health. Drink with moderation.